How To Answer Those “Weird” Supplemental Essay Questions

Colleges from across the country just released their supplemental essay questions for the 2022-23 application cycle, and while most of them are relatively straightforward, some are downright bizarre.

Many of the seemingly strangest questions don’t even require a full essay response. In fact, short answer questions are common among selective colleges and responses could range anywhere from one word to 100 words.

Short Answer Questions

Here is a sampling of some of the wackiest short answer questions we’ve come across this year:

Chapman University: Name one dish you would cook for our admission team. (1 word/phrase)

Elon University: What three emojis/GIFs do you use most often? Why? (30 words)

Princeton University: What song represents the soundtrack of your life at this moment? (50 words)

Pitzer College: Two of our favorite murals on campus have quotes that read, “Be your own weird” and “You are of this place – it is changing you”. If you could add an inspirational quote or art piece to our campus, what would it be and why? (100 words)

University of Maryland: My favorite thing about last Tuesday was… (160 characters)

University of Southern California: What is your favorite snack? (25 characters)

Essay Questions

Other colleges want more in-depth responses to their wacky questions, asking for an essay anywhere from 250 words to two pages in length. Some of our favorites for this year are:

Barnard College: Pick one woman — a historical figure, fictitious character, or modern individual — to converse with for an hour and explain your choice. Why does this person intrigue you? What would you talk about? What questions would you ask them? (300 words)

Providence College: If you could have a theme song, what would it be and why? (250-500 words)

University of Chicago: Was it a cat I saw? Yo-no-na-ka, ho-ka-ho-ka na-no-yo (Japanese for “the world is a warm place”). Moze jutro ta dama da tortu jezom (Polish for “maybe tomorrow that lady will give a cake to the hedgehogs”). Share a palindrome in any language, and give it a backstory. (1-2 pages)

University of Virginia: What website is the internet missing? (250 words)

Stanford University: Virtually all of Stanford's undergraduates live on campus. Write a note to your future roommate that reveals something about you or that will help your roommate – and us – get to know you better. (250 words)

Beyond Words

On rare occasions, colleges remove words from the equation entirely. Rice University decided to do this when they invented their “Rice Box” question: “In keeping with Rice’s long-standing tradition, please share an image of something that appeals to you.”

If a picture is worth a thousand words, then this is the longest supplemental essay you could write!

Okay, But How Do I Answer These “Weird” Questions?

Let’s start with why colleges ask these types of questions in the first place. Usually, there are two reasons:

  1. They want to show you that their college environment is creative and thought-provoking.

  2. They want to know how creative and thoughtful you are to see if you’re a good match for their college.

In order to show colleges that you would be a good match for them, it’s important to do your research. Read up on each colleges’ mission statements to learn what the school values, then draw upon your personality traits and experiences that best align with those values.

Be mindful, however, of trying to present as someone you think a college wants you to be. More than anything, colleges want to cultivate diverse campuses full of interesting people pursuing unique goals and passions. So when you answer these questions, endeavor to be completely and unequivocally yourself.

Being yourself can be hard, especially under pressure, so remember to trust your instincts. It’s remarkably easy to overthink these questions, wondering how the admissions committee will interpret your choice of Ben & Jerry’s flavor or soundtrack song. You need to put time and thought into each response, of course, but since wacky questions are designed to tease out your quirks, your first instinct might be your best one.

Lastly, share your answers and essays with someone who knows you and can offer a nuanced perspective. At LogicPrep, our experienced College Advisors and Essay Coaches get to know our students personally over the course of several months or even years. We not only help you find your best-fit colleges and edit your writing; we help you recognize and draw upon the most interesting aspects of your personality for each and every piece of your application.

To learn more about how LogicPrep prepares you for the wacky world of college applications, book a consultation today!

And as a reward for reading through this entire post, here is my absolute favorite “weird” essay question of the year, courtesy of the University of Vermont: “Which Ben & Jerry’s ice cream flavor (real or imagined) best describes you?” (500 words). Yum!